(OT) If you had to name a Sandwich Captain of your Sandwich Team, what kind of sandwich would it be?

[Eleven]

I just had to revisit the doughnut thread from four years ago, didn't I?

 

Anyway.  I nominate the BLT.  The best sandwich of all time.

 

And PA, durst you deem this thread "booze-inspired," as you demeaned my nice doughnut thread, know that I am drinking herbal tea.  And, regrettably, not eating a BLT.

[LGR4GM]

I would call it the sh!thouse or sh!thole sandwhich, it would be filled with bolgona, orange mustard, with brunost cheese, between two pieces of yellow rye bread that smelled funny.

Edited January 17, 2018 by SkuggaLiger

[inkman]

A hot dog

[Drunkard]

Not sure if there are any Jimmy Johns sandwich shops in WNY but I'd go with the JJ gargantuan. Awesome sandwich, epsecially with extra hot peppers.

[sabills]

A hot dog

I'm amazed it took this long into the thread.

[ubkev]

All the sandwiches!!!!!! Oh My God! It's like choosing your favorite child, but harder, as a sandwich will never disappoint you! OK, here we go...

 

Turkey, mayo, Swiss, lettuce, bacon, thousand island on sourdough, toasted.

 

French Dip

 

Peanut mother butter and jelly!

 

Italian

 

Fried egg sandwich

 

Meatball

 

Sausage and peppers

 

jesus henry christ, I could go on for days. I'm not even sure I've named my favorite yet! 

A hot dog

you

[Weave]

A hot dog

 

 

I'm amazed it took this long into the thread.

 

and that's when the argument started.

[Taro T]

Would probably go w/ the old Jimbo's Beef & Sirloin which was basically a very good cheeseburger w/ shaved sirloin topping it. Yum. It was probably close to 1,000 calories but absolutely delicious.

[Weave]

Eleven,  I think you've actually done this one before.

 

Cubano would be my choice.  Ham, roast pork, cheese.

 

Omm nom nom....

[Sabel79]

If in WNY: a beef on weck. I had one when home for the holidays and cried for an hour.

 

Elsewhere: take as much corned beef as you can wedge between two slices of rye and put a little mustard on it.

[ubkev]

Eleven,  I think you've actually done this one before.

 

Cubano would be my choice.  Ham, roast pork, cheese.

 

Omm nom nom....

and i'll take that with an appetizer of fried gator! 

[Wyldnwoody44]

Is this gonna fuel the grilled cheese debate again?!?!

[ubkev]

Is this gonna fuel the grilled cheese debate again?!?!

Not unless you're putting it on your list, and Randall wants to bitch about it. 

[darksabre]

My sandwich Captain plays with an edge. Always a little salty. Dedicated to sating hunger all day every day. Even when it's not the best, it's still good. Don't know what to order? No problem. Here you go.

 

My sandwich Captain is the Reuben.

[Winston]

Born in Pennsylvania, my captain could wear the C in probably any state or city. He has greasy, slicked back hair. There is a simplicity to his game, but it is still miraculously well-rounded and delightful. His go-to shootout move is top cheese. Plays best with a basket of fries on his wing.

 

Philly cheese steak

 

(still no mushrooms ????)

Edited January 17, 2018 by EichSnipe

[CallawaySabres]

Toasted everything bagel

Fried turkey over the oven, same with salami

Melted swiss

Fried egg over easy

Add shredded lettuce, ketchup and hot sauce

 

Hello Sunday breakfast

[LGR4GM]

Not sure if there are any Jimmy Johns sandwich shops in WNY but I'd go with the JJ's gargantuan. Awesome sandwich, epsecially with extra hot peppers.

JJ's never impressed me.

 

Wegmans chicken finger sub. Blue cheese, lettuce, tomato, provolone and cucumber. Medium wing sauce

Edited January 17, 2018 by SkuggaLiger

[Sabel79]

JJ's is emergency food, much like McDonalds.

[MattPie]

I concur, JJ's is fine, but it's Mighty Taco to Taco Bell; a better than Subway but not by that much. Firehouse Subs has some good points but for me, Wegmans and a local chain called Primo's sit at the top of the heap.

 

Everyday Sandwich Captain: Primo's Sharp Italian. Crusty, chewy, spicy, sharp, and fills the net.

Fancy-pants generational Captain: Gorett's Original Sin from Iron Abbey in Horsham, PA. Brioche, roast beef, chorizo, gouda, soaked in beer gravy with a fried egg on top.

Edited January 17, 2018 by MattiPaj

[That Aud Smell]

My sandwich Captain plays with an edge. Always a little salty. Dedicated to sating hunger all day every day. Even when it's not the best, it's still good. Don't know what to order? No problem. Here you go.

 

My sandwich Captain is the Reuben.

Elite sandwich, but that’s Marian Hossa. Excellent, versatile, reliable, all-purpose. But not the captain.

[pi2000]

bologna... leads by example, well liked in the locker room, plays a strong two way game.

[PASabreFan]

My sandwich Captain plays with an edge. Always a little salty. Dedicated to sating hunger all day every day. Even when it's not the best, it's still good. Don't know what to order? No problem. Here you go.

 

My sandwich Captain is the Reuben.

People need to go back and edit their posts to be more like this. You've got to make the captain tie-in.

Edited January 17, 2018 by PASabreFan

[That Aud Smell]

I’ll go with an Italian hero.

 

I’ll give A’s to meatball and reuben.

 

P.s. We can use sandwiches that are sorta known as subs, right?

Edited January 17, 2018 by That Aud Smell

[Brawndo]

Turkey Club, any sandwich that requires toothpicks to hold it together is the way to go

[ubkev]

I’ll go with an Italian hero.

 

I’ll give A’s to meatball amd reuben.

 

P.s. We can use sandwiches that are sorta known as subs, right?

Yes