Not sure what the point you are making.
There are a whole bunch of mathematically inclined people mining data to see what conventional wisdom holds merit. So far, as far as I can determine, the current research and subsequent conclusions say that hitting the other guy has no bearing on wins and losses (and perhaps is even slightly negatively correlated.).
So when fans clamor for more hitting, it should be because it is for their entertainment, not because they are frustrated with the outcome of the game.