Against. They are not finishing bottom 5.
Let's make this easy on @Buffalonill. Bottom 5 he wins. Playoffs or top 5 non-playoffs* we win. Everything in between is a push. Sound fair?
(To be clear: Top-5 non-playoff means one of the five best records by point% of teams not qualifying for the playoffs. Bottom 5 means one of the five worst point% in the league.)