Jump to content

3putt

Members
  • Posts

    5,232
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by 3putt

  1. Stone Harbor and Cape May are nice
  2. I couldn't be A.Devils fan if that was the steady diet of play. Boring.
  3. The Devils should not be allowed to play that boring trap in the largest media market in NA. It is a sacrilege
  4. 3putt

    Tank 3.0

    I am not advocating, simply pointing out that to eliminate what is perceived as an ill would require killing the patient. I see nothing wrong with starting over. Clean house. And rebuild. I think that the lottery system is idiotic. I am however old school. I don't believe you can have a draft system, which creates an incentive to position your organization to gain top talent you would otherwise not get, and then complain when those organizations play the system to max advantage. Dfl should pick first.
  5. 3putt

    Tank 3.0

    A draft is designed to induce sustainable competitive balance. It garauntees a bottom team a shot at direction altering talent. If you want to deter tanking, eliminate the draft altogethor and make all unsigned age eligible players free agents. No draft, no tank.
  6. 3putt

    Tank 3.0

    And you can be assured that when Toews or Kane is long in the tooth and the Hawks miss the playoffs, they will win the lottery and get the next McDavid.
  7. Ok, I'll play. First Jones' pedigree far exceeded Lehner's if for no ther reason he did not miss half a season with concussion issues. So argument doesn't work. Lehner was in the Lack, Talbot category the market value was a second or third. That Murray believed he was getting a #1 is also irrelevant. Number ones were available for less cost. Murray went to an auto lot and said I want a pickup. The salesman says we have 3 all in black. Murray says he'll pay double for a red one. The salesman has a black one painted and walks off with double the market value for the same vehicle. You make distinctions between player a and player b when the production is equivalent. Under those circumstances the market value is the same. That he prefers one over the other and pays a premium for it is the objection some, including myself, have with how he makes trades. The improvement in the team is obvious but is that due to the specific addition or adding a player of a certain style? Is it the maturation ahead of schedule of Sam and Jack? Would we be in the same position with a full season of Lack or better with Jones? Simply saying we're better so Murray shouldn't be criticized is specious at best. In business success is often measured by roi. Are we getting good roi? These are legit questions. I like this team. I like rooting for Jack and Sam and Risto and Jake. Kane is fun but frustrating at times. But all in all enjoyable. But I dont measure the health of the team on my enjoyment index. We suffered for 2 plus years all the while accumulating capital in the form of picks. It is not unreasonable to ponder whether we have spent that capital wisely. IMHO, the jury is still out. And again I like GMTM. It doesn't mean I can't disagree with some of his moves. That is the inherent right of any fan.
  8. http://www.eliteprospects.com/player.php?player=312213 Dominant, tenacious, engaged. Plays in the OHL and has adapted to the North American game.
  9. Panarin locking up the Calder. 2 g 1a v Jets.
  10. I can give case cites. Btw, I like Murray. I just wish he would not fixate so much on what he wants.
  11. But this fails as well. We knew what Neuvirth was and Halak. Is Lehner any better? At this point the jury is still out. Those two would not have cost an asset. The unsaid premise is that immediacy was required. I think that was the error. A 3 year deal, with an eye to moves to bolster the organization top to bottom was the wiser choice. Modern scouting is much more exact. The top guys are not reaches. Boeser or White in the organization would calm alot of the who do get to play with Jack speculation. A different approach but the one I was in favor of. Jmho ymmv.
  12. I hear this refrain and simply can't join in. GMTM has a eye for talent but its not unbiased. The issue I have with him is he seems to pay sticker price. Kane was going to be dealt either at the deadline or over the summer. The premium he paid to get him before was exorbitant imho. I would have stopped at Lemieux. The first was too much. It has nothing to do with contracts but rather having more ammo for the next deal. Lehner was a huge overpay. If your wife came home with a 2014 corolla and "only" paid 40k, you would be less than happy. I think that is what many here question about GMTM. The winning trades meme is misplaced as well. Its asset management. RIAs go to jail for overpaying like Tim does. Jmho.
  13. If we take a dman, Sergachev would be my first choice. Kid is going to be a stud.
  14. Pa of course. Can you imagine his posts? They would be epic.
  15. Hoffman sees his shadow on Groundhog Day and goes to sleep until Spring.
  16. That was weak. call.
  17. Wow Sam won that race.
  18. Nelson should train in the Geico gym
  19. That was special
  20. Jack WTH?
  21. Larry taken it to Kadri. Noice.
  22. NICE PASS.
×
×
  • Create New...