freester

Do you think any team would trade us a first round pick for Montour?

I disagree. Botteril has made 1 good move that being acquiring Joker. The Skinner move has proven to be a disaster and his contract will soon be among the worst albatrosses in the league. Wasting first round pick on Montour was idiotic as well as giving up picks for Miller for him to sit in press box. Hiring Housley was a terrible move for a first time GM to hire a first time coach. Botteril has mismanaged the cap in virtually every move he’s made. And let us not forget Botteril made one of the worst trades in NHL history and has still not replaced ROR. TM acquired 2 top 6 forwards Including a Center and a physical power forward and a very good goalie ( who had mental health issues)

Not to nitpick but Guhle played almost 16 minutes according to stats and didn’t make any glaring errors that I saw. Guhle is also younger and less developed than Montour.

I’m becoming a bit concerned about the Skinner situation. The contract was always terrible from the get go but Skinner is not producing at all. I want to believe he just needs a decent Center and isn’t mailing it in. Hopefully we can get him some better line mates and he can start producing.

Well at least we gave away a 1st round pick for nothing and can overpay him this off season. ?

No , TM made mistakes but he was infinitely better than Botteril the buffoon.

Did anyone think Montour looked significantly better than Guhle on defense? I would say they were comparable. Another terrible Botteril trade.

I’m just comparing the team from last year to this year. It seems to be significantly improved.

We could start insufferable posts that we should have hired Dave Tippets. He seems to be doing a good job in Edmonton.

I would definitely resign Girgs for cheap deal. Get rid of Vesey, Bogo, Frolik, Sheary, Erod. I don’t think Tage will be ready to contribute next year.

Your analogies are out of whack. 1. we have a good backup goalie in Ullmark we need a starter number 1 goalie like Ryan Miller 2. We have Mair and Gaustad already in Larson and Girgensons. That is not what we need. We need a true #2 Center like Cirelli, RNH etc. We also need a #3 Center 3. The log line is a 4th line not a 3rd line. Mojo belongs as a winger on 3rd line. 4. We need some physicality on defense besides Risto. 5.Tim Connolly 2006 playoffs was amazing

This is a terrible idea. A terrible GM, a first time NHL coach, a team president without NHL management experience and a failed assistant GM. I don’t want Botteril even selling concessions at Key Bank

Chiarelli is infinitely better than Botteril. At least Adam Larson can play. The pieces we got for ROR were garbage and salary cap dumps

Montour trade was not good at all. He is mediocre and no better than Colin Miller or Guhle. Boteril will also overpay Montour this offseason.

Botteril could get a contract extension.

NBCSN just showed Sabres fans wearing bags over their heads. This is great. Hopefully the Pegulas saw this and fire Botteril immediately.

Did anyone hear chanting tonight of “Fire Botteril “. The Pegulas need to hear that loud and frequently.

He’s only been there less than one year and he’s already made 1 great move unloading Lucic. He’s infinitely better than Botteril.

When you have a competent GM anything is possible

We could have had Draisaitl instead of Reinhart. That’s the tragedy of our own doing

He had a very good relationship with Jack and Sam as well as GMTM. He just wanted a good contract. When Botteril was hired he decided that Kane was the problem and made no attempt to resign him.

And Botteril got extremely lucky that Berglunds large cap hit suddenly disappeared. Botteril must be terminated immediately

No evidence whatsoever for this statement. In fact he said he was upset he never received an offer.

Kane’s contract is much better than Skinner and he provides a physical presence which we are desperately lacking.

Stop trying to defend Botteril. He is utterly incompetent in every respect. He is among the worst GMs in NHL history Terrible trades, terrible contracts, terrible coaching hires. Every minute he is still here sets us up for future failure. I can’t wait till he is finally fired.