Colten Ellis Love Fest

[Taro T]

16 minutes ago, PromoTheRobot said:

People were losing their minds about having 3 goalies again. And some had the usual who-the-****-is-this-guy reaction 

Not on the 1st 2 pages of the thread announcing he'd been claimed.  Didn't bother to reread all 6 pages again, but don't recall any sort of preponderance of posts to that effect.  Your memory of that day seems to be coming through a filter.

People did complain about the 3 headed goalie monster again later on, but there was no overwhelming concensus that Ellis should be the odd man out.  Actually, if there was what could be considered a concensus, would say that UPL being the odd man out was where that was heading.

So, again, disagree with the contention that "(p)eople hated the waiver pickup of Ellis!"  That simply wasn't the case.

[PromoTheRobot]

2 hours ago, LGR4GM said:

We can look back too:

 

I only got ten three pages on. Mostly just completing about Adams. 😂

1 minute ago, Taro T said:

Not on the 1st 2 pages of the thread announcing he'd been claimed.  Didn't bother to reread all 6 pages again, but don't recall any sort of preponderance of posts to that effect.  Your memory of that day seems to be coming through a filter.

People did complain about the 3 headed goalie monster again later on, but there was no overwhelming concensus that Ellis should be the odd man out.  Actually, if there was what could be considered a concensus, would say that UPL being the odd man out was where that was heading.

So, again, disagree with the contention that "(p)eople hated the waiver pickup of Ellis!"  That simply wasn't the case.

No one loved it. A few said maybe he's something. Most just used it to dump on Adams.

[Doohickie]

4 hours ago, PromoTheRobot said:

Ha ha, any deal for UPL will be derided so does it matter? People hated the waiver pickup of Ellis! My point is the Sabres should try to get the most for UPL or any player they move. Of course a clock is ticking when they will need the roster spot a third goalie is taking up, so there's that. But that deadline isn't upon them yet.

We don't know what is going on or what calls have been made or taken. But our favorite pastime is creating our own stories.

Put him on the waiver wire.  If he clears, he goes to Rochester.  If someone picks him up, his contract is off our books.  Win win.

[Taro T]

1 minute ago, PromoTheRobot said:

I only got ten three pages on. Mostly just completing about Adams. 😂

No one loved it. A few said maybe he's something. Most just used it to dump on Adams.

There is a WORLD of difference between "no one lov(ing) it" and "(p)eople hated the waiver pickup of Ellis!"  Do you HONESTLY not see that?  And THAT contention that "(p)eople hated (it)" is untrue at worst and flat out hyperbolic at best.

And actually, there were about 3 people that were really happy about the deal.  So, even the "no one loved it" is a bit hyperbolic too.

Yes, again  people were primarily in the "he has to be better than Georgiev" camp (which turned out to be true unsurprisingly) and "guess this means that UPL might be out for a fairly long time" (which wasn't quite as correct, though it did take a couple of weeks for him to be ready again).

And, while SOME used it to dump on Adams, wouldn't even say "MOST (emphasis mine) just used it to dump on Adams."  Personally would say that overall the attitude on it was "don't know if it'll work, but it might, and it gets Georgiev out of the picture and lets them follow their plan for Levi of keeping him on the farm this year unless something absolutely catastrophic happens, so cool." 

And even a few of those "dump on Adams" posts were of the "he should be making way more waiver claims than he does because you never know when you'll find a diamond in the rough and they have a really hard time bringing in guys on the fringes that end up exceeding expectations and actually sticking" nature and not of the "wtf did he claim THIS guy" nature.

 

[Pimlach]

4 hours ago, Taro T said:

To the 1st bolded.  Almost everybody's reaction to the signing was "well, we know nothing at all about him, but he has to be better than Georgiev" and "guess this means UPL is going to be out a while."

Most people said they thought the guy might turn out to be good but really didn't know.  There were several "goalies are voodoo" posts.  About 2 people said it was a horrible pickup, so yes, "people" hated it, but the naysayers were in the VAST minority on this one.  And about 3 people really liked the pick.  An opinion that was also in the minority.

Which brings us to the 2nd bolded ...

[Weave]

I see Promo is back to making up reasons to hate the fanbase he hates that he is part of again.

Sorry, not again. Still.  The correct word there is still.

[PromoTheRobot]

5 minutes ago, Weave said:

I see Promo is back to making up reasons to hate the fanbase he hates that he is part of again.

Sorry, not again. Still.  The correct word there is still.

Ha ha ha.  This site is 95% hating everything about the team. But I'm the problem. Never change.

Edited 32 minutes ago by PromoTheRobot

[Weave]

1 minute ago, PromoTheRobot said:

Ha ha ha.  This site is 95% hating everything about the team. But I'm the problem. Never change.

You’re right. The fans are the problem.

You silly bear.

[PromoTheRobot]

Just now, Weave said:

You’re right. The fans are the problem.

You silly bear.

I never said fans are a "problem." Although the word "fans" is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. 🤣