I will 100% agree that Dino BBQ is vastly overrated. What a shame that the NE Patriots (among countless other visitors to Rochester) have been subjected to it.
Also, Tahou's does not make the best garbage plate.
Anchor Bar in both Rochester and Buffalo were terrible experiences.
Worst restaurant in 585? Davincis. Underrated? Agatinas.
Great BBQ- Sticky Lips.
Great Subs- Dibellas
Great Mexican- El Dorado
Best Bar Food- Windjammers (wet Cajun wings/chicken fingers, harbor fries, great burgers, salami chips)
Also, Perri's sells the fiestada pizzas we used to have in school...awesome.