Thanks for that post.
A couple comments. First, I think there is an argument to be made that construction workers, loggers, iron workers, truckers, etc., provide plenty of tangible public service even though they are first and foremost working for private enterprises. The lumber they harvest, the foundations they lay, the goods they transport, are all done for us, and done at a cost that goes beyond just financial. These people work terrible hours for terrible pay in terrible conditions to make sure that rest of us can live comfortable lives. That sounds like public service to me. Second, I hope no one is construing my comments as unappreciative towards police, fire fighters, etc. My problem is more with the intense culture of worship that seems to surround them now, whether they want it or not. And I know plenty of ex-soldiers who don't want it. They don't want to be elevated so highly over the people they served. I would like to look at this whole thing and believe that there is nothing inappropriate going on. But I can't get there anymore.