Jump to content

pi2000

Members
  • Posts

    9,344
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by pi2000

  1. 5 hours ago, LGR4GM said:

    Just listened to Granato on wgr. If a coach can lose the players, they can lose the fans. Granato has lost me, so disappointed in him. 

    He was what they needed 2 years ago.

    It's time to move on, they're ready to take that next step.

    • Agree 1
  2. 46 minutes ago, mjd1001 said:

    I think it isn't just one or two players, its a team wide/organization wide thing:

    -Okposo...hes a 'vet' but he makes plenty of mistakes in his own zone.  Leaves open areas, doesn't know where to go. He never has played for a team in his career that excelled defensively.

    -Peterka, Benson and Krebs do a lot of 'stick waving' They could engage people more than they do.

    -Cozens.  Probably the worst player at abandoning his man and leaving wide open areas of the ice for opposing players to walk in, just so he chases the puck. I know others love him, but He might be in the bottom 10% of players who know how to play in the defensive zone.

    -Mitts has gotten better, but he still does a lot of stick waving. Skinner likes to hang around the blue line and not go in too deep to help.  Tuch and Thompson have good games and bad games.

    The only person I rarely see out of position, rarely leaving his side of the ice wide open to chase a puck is Girgensons.  But a lot of people want him off this team for whatever reason, even though he might be the single one, the only sound forward on this team in his own end.

    ...and hence a coaching problem.    Good coaches don't let their players get away with the stick waving and fly-bys.    Granato lets it happen by not holding them accountable.    Don't get me wrong, he certainly knows the game well enough to identify these things and provide corrective instruction.... however that's not enough.  

    And now he's at a point where he just like "***** it, go play how you guys want to go play and let the chips fall where they may".      He's essentially saying he's lost control of the group and it's up to them to decide how they want to play.     What value does he provide other than "the players like me and want to win for me because I'm nice to them".      That's loser talk.

    • Agree 1
  3. 10 minutes ago, Marvin said:

    Don't exclude the players' responsibility for the defencive failures.

    If it's one or 2 or a small group of players who are not listening, then he needs to hold them accountable and limit their ice time until they fall in line. 

    That said, I won't completely absolve the players... however, if the entire team is faltering, then that's either a system problem or a coaching problem, or both. 

    This first third of the season seemed like a discovery process... can they reduce goals against by playing a more defensively responsible system?    The answer was yes, but they sacrificed too much offense in the process.    That, combined with some poor goaltending (thanks Kevyn!) and you're gonna be on the wrong end of it most nights... and Granato's answer is just "let's go back to firewagon hockey!".     I don't see this as progress, it's regression.

    IMO the solution is two-fold...  solidify the goaltending position and find a coach who can teach this young impressionable group how to play a winning brand of pro hockey.     

  4. So we're back to firewagon hockey which is fun, but isn't a sustainable winning brand of hockey.

    IMO, thi is an indictment of Granato and his staff... namely, their inability to implement a defensively responsible system while not completely neutralizing their ability to generate offense.   

    This failed attempt has likely cost them a playoff birth.

    • Like (+1) 1
  5. 19 minutes ago, LTS said:

    Okay.. sample size of 1?  Are there others?  Was it even attributed to not being healed fully versus just another incident that would have resulted in the same injury even if it hadn't happened before?

    I'm legit asking. While I am reading what you wrote I am also looking over at this Aaron Rodgers scenario wondering...

    Standard recovery for achilles repair is 6 months (26 weeks).   He's at 24 weeks 5 days.    

    I have no medical training nor any specific reason to doubt the Sabres team of medical professionals.... 

    I'm simply pointing out that his return, IMO, is sooner than expected and I hope he doesn't re-injure it as a result, ala Pacioretty who re-tore his at 23 weeks post-op.

  6. 29 minutes ago, LGR4GM said:

    Jack Quinn being added to the 3rd line like:

    Rubbing Season 3 GIF by The Simpsons

    This soon? The injury recovery time was 4-6months and we are at the end of month 6. They've been ramping him up for almost 4 full weeks at this point. 

    I really hope this doesn't backfire.    Achilles recovery is no joke, there's countless cases of athletes returning to competition too soon because they feel great, only to re-injure themselves and never be the same.     

    My hope was they would proceed cautiously and keep him out until Feb at the earliest.     Fingers crossed.

    • Like (+1) 1
    • Agree 2
    • dislike 1
  7. 14 minutes ago, Crusader1969 said:

    How does keeping Benson with Thompson and Tuch sound 

    Skinner to play with Krebs and Quinn as line #3 

    He makes players around him better. 

    That said I thought he was best served going back to juniors but he seems to be getting better and better each game as he adjusts to the speed.

    • Like (+1) 1
  8. 4 minutes ago, thewookie1 said:

    This team truly is an enigma; you could honestly convince me we have two teams and that they alternate who's playing.

    Benson could easily become something akin to either Skinner with Defensive play or even Marchand

    He reminds me of Doug Gilmour, but man he looks like a little kid out there.  He just keeps making plays tho it's incredible he dropped to 13th.   It's exciting to think about what he can become after he matures physically.

    Kudos to KA for not passing on him like a dozen other GMs did.

    • Like (+1) 2
    • Agree 1
×
×
  • Create New...