Ten Players Per Week

[Taro T]

Again, I am VERY sorry for the length of time this has taken, and I'm concerned about the integrity of the poll for the next group because of the length of time that has passed. It's not deliberate; I had some emergency surgery (happy to still be with you all), and although I'm mostly recovered, there's a lot of make-up to do at work.

 

I'll leave the comments open for the next few days and will shut 'em down when I open the poll for the next group of players.

 

Anyway, here are the results--some surprising, some not so much (Connolly). And yeah, I have to manually type the results. The surveymonkey free program offers very little over our own interface here. It was easier to just use a calculator last year.

 

 

 

1. Enroth (N=64)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 21.9%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 62.5%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 15.6%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 0%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 0%

 

Average: 4.06.

 

 

3. Leopold (N=64)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 3.1%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 45.3%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 45.3%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 6.3%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 0%

 

Average: 3.45.

 

 

4. Montador (N=64)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 0%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 6.3%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 62.5%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 28.1%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 3.1%

 

Average: 2.72.

 

 

6. Weber (N=64)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 15.6%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 65.6%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 15.6%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 3.1%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 0%

 

Average: 3.94.

 

 

8. McCormick (N=62)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 9.7%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 48.4%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 37.1%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 4.8%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 0%

 

Average: 3.63.

 

 

9. Roy (N=63)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 12.7%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 58.7%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 23.8%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 4.8%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 0%

 

Average: 3.79.

 

 

12. Mancari (N=63)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 3.2%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 4.8%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 63.5%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 19.0%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 9.5%

 

Average: 2.73.

 

 

 

17. Gragnani (N=64)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 34.4%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 51.6%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 14.1%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 0%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 0%

 

Average: 4.20

 

 

19. Connolly (N=64)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 1.6%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 0%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 9.4%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 39.1%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 50%

 

Average: 1.64

 

 

20. Neidermayer (N=64)

 

5: Must keep under any circumstances: 0%

4: Would like to keep; would trade only for a great return (if under contract) or would pay a premium to re-sign (if FA): 17.2%

3: Don't care if he stays or goes; would make a fair trade (if under contract) or pay somewhat above current salary to re-sign (if FA): 37.5%

2: Don't want him on the team, really; would trade for a somewhat lesser return (if under contract) or sign at current or lower salary (if FA): 34.4%

1: Get this guy off of the team, no matter what it takes: 10.9%

 

Average: 2.61.

Surprised Weber wasn't rated higher. Surprised that over 1 in 3 responders said to keep Gragnani at all costs.

 

How did MANCARI end up w/ the same number of fans as Leopold?

 

Roy ended up higher rated than I'd've expected but about where he should be.

 

And was the 1 poster LQ or TC's mommy?

 

Get well 11. Poll can wait.

[OverPowerYou]

Surprised Weber wasn't rated higher. Surprised that over 1 in 3 responders said to keep Gragnani at all costs.

 

How did MANCARI end up w/ the same number of fans as Leopold?

 

Roy ended up higher rated than I'd've expected but about where he should be.

 

And was the 1 poster LQ or TC's mommy?

 

Get well 11. Poll can wait.

 

 

What surprised me was how many people want Mancari off the team. After 5 or so Years he's coming along and everyone wants to get rid of him? Makes little sense to me.

[X. Benedict]

What surprised me was how many people want Mancari off the team. After 5 or so Years he's coming along and everyone wants to get rid of him? Makes little sense to me.

 

His upside is probably depth forward. Not a game changer.