Long time simce posting here but just wanted to weigh in and post what probably isn't that unique of an opinion at this point.
For those who say that the NCAA should give the PSU football program should receive the death penalty are asking for it for the wrong reasons. Most people want to "send a message" to other coaches, AD's, trustees, etc. that "this type of coverup will not be tolerated." Anyone who thinks that shutting the program down will deter anyone from covering up a scandal in the future to save their hides is fooling themselves. Bad people will do what they do where they want to do it until they get caught. For the NCAA to shut down PSU football is reactionary and will accomplish nothing.
If PSU itself decides to shut down the football team for a year, two years, or indefinitely as a way of cleaning house and moving on is a different story. Penn State has to heal its relationship with the local community, and build outward to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and beyond. Some will see the navy blue and white uniforms and only be reminded of the crimes that were allowed flourish there. I will be one of those people. However, as we all know, sports can be the source of inspiration. If the team is allowed to have it's season, the players and coaches need to get out there in the community and give their time to children's groups. This can be done parallel to having a team.
My point is that shutting down the football team as a punitive measure is short-sighted. It robs the university of a chance to repair an image that was destroyed by 5 arrogant men in positions of power. If the university will put more focus on community service from its athletes, then I'm all for having a football season.