Jump to content

Neo

Members
  • Posts

    5,122
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Neo

  1. Let's say fortune smiles on us and the Islanders finish last and/or win the lottery and McDavid/Eichel turn into everything they're hyped to be. Does this go down as the greatest trade in franchise history? It has to be top-3 (Hasek,LaFontaine), right?

     

    I've always viewed the LaFontaine trade as a good trade, but not a great trade. Fun fact. LaFontaine scored 385 points as a Sabre, and 447 total NHL points, after the trade to Buffalo. Turgeon scored 1,004 NHL Points after the trade to the NYI.

     

    LaFontaine is iconic. He was expensive.

     

    Oops, just saw PA's comment. Same sentiment.

  2.  

     

    Tim Murray doesn't get hired, hockey organizations form around him.

     

    Awesome ....

     

     

    I watched his press conference, today. I have this sensation that I'm watching a savant. He was put on earth to be a hockey GM. I'm not convinced he could order wine at dinner or pick up dry cleaning. He is, however, at peace and in control, traveling a path he sees clearly. Like many extraordinary talents, he is frustrated because others seem to be slow on the uptake. He almost seems confused that no one sees what he sees. I find myself more fearful that he'll get bored than I am that he'll fail.

     

    I know, we'll all know more in three years. I described him in the magical terms that I've learned are ultimately revealed to be incomplete. I get it. Man, what a first impression ...

     

     

     

     

  3. In the OPs defense, not that he needs it, I understand the question when asked today. The fact that it's a different question over time is true, but not relevant to me today. Let's ask again then, as well.

     

    Obviously, the Reinhart pick is the most meaningful. I like it very much. But, in the spirit of initial impressions, I voted Lemieux. I expected less "thrill" at 31, and got more. The video of Brendan, and the separate video of Claude, are awesome.

     

    Reinhart, expectation met.

     

    Lemieux, expectation exceeded.

     

     

  4.  

     

    My hands remain at my sides.

     

    Everyone talking about St. Louis: Remember when there was a website dedicated to "has he scored for the Rangers yet?" Remember articles like this? http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1999389-martin-st-louis-is-an-easy-scapegoat-for-new-york-rangers-offensive-woes

     

    When it's a Sabre (Vanek), we really criticize this type of streakiness. St. Louis was almost a bust; now it's the greatest deadline deal ever.

     

     

    Butch Goring ....

  5. Can we all agree that, throughout his entire career, Miller has been a good to very good goaltender who can sometimes play lights out and, on occasion, gives up soft goals at what seem like the worst possible time?

     

    For what it's worth, the conversation around Bflo's defense v the Blue's defense has merit. From what I saw watching the Blues after the trade, Bflo's d-zone posture is more aggressive with more attacking the puck and trying to eliminate passing lanes and allowing Miller to face the shooter.

     

    As said upthread, the Blues emphasized shot blocking which, in a sense, required Miller to lean toward the open player. After years of coming out and challenging shooters, he had to stay back so he'd have a better chance of moving laterally to get square after the pass.

     

    Regardless of whether it's Call of Duty or the NHL, if you are most comfortable in being aggressive in your style of play, dialing it back feels like you're not as engaged and are much more reactionary than you'd like to be. And that, in my humblest of opinions, is why he struggled down the stretch.

     

    Can I say I'm down with this?

  6. December 2, 1981. I was 20 and a junior at UB. I had a job delivering packaged goods with a retail store near the Main Street campus. I heard a radio story explaining that Gare, Schoenfeld and Smith were traded to Detroit. It was emotional for all fans. For me, it separated my time as a boy, cheering my heros, from my time as an adult, following my team. The passion is unchanged, but the magic of youth disappeared. I grew up with Schoney and Gare. The finals, 50 goal seasons, and fights in the Zamboni corridor went away. Hockey became a sport and a business to me. Important, yes, but painted with the realism brush that touches one thing after another as boys become men. I still love Christmas, but smile when I remember leaving coco and carrots for a jolly old man and reindeer.

  7. I've confessed before. I'm no scout.

     

    I saw much (all?) of the USA WJC tournament. I absolutely loved Fasching. He became my favorite non-Sabre to watch. Big body, great hands, head and heart. Seemed pretty quick, especially for a big man. He skates. I'd say he was a man among boys, but at the WJC, that description isn't as powerful as it would be if he appeared that way in the NHL.

     

    Steep price. I suspect he's been on TM's radar for some time. As others have said, I appreciate Murray's strength of conviction. He must have been aware of the risks - inconsistency - and moved anyway.

  8. I'm looking at this as follows.

     

    This was either a one off, solely LaFontaine issue, and there will be no domino effect with Nolan, Murray and Patrick. In that case, the hockey product survives and life goes on. Not ideal, but management changes are part of business. If other dominos fall, all bets are off and we're back to a bad product without a vision and direction.

     

    In either case, the handling can only be described as amateurish and bungled. Contrast fanfare and press conferences with leaks and terse statements. Consider the timing. This happened hours after the trade of an iconic player and in the midst of a seven day trading period that the franchise has pointed to as critical in order to climb out of the cellar.

     

    I can get over LaFontaine leaving. The lingering concern is the management of the franchise. Competent professionals making considered decisions, mutually respecting one another, would have staged this to occur post trade deadline and held a cordial joint press conference. Twitter leaks, radio silence, terse three paragraph announcements after the news is already out all point to a fire drill.

     

    We may or may not learn what the issues were or who made what decisions. I do believe one thing, though. For the past twenty four hours, everyone in the organization was scrambling to respond to something no one in the organization was guiding or managing. That's not usually a successful strategy.

     

    What I know: The Sabres have passionate fans and an owner with tremendous financial resources.

     

    What I don't know: Anything else.

×
×
  • Create New...