Jump to content

Iron Crotch

Members
  • Posts

    10,616
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Iron Crotch

  1. 4 hours ago, Swedesessed said:

    It might seem crazy to think that the Sabres can make a massive leap forward and even get into the playoffs.


    Ask New Jersey fans this time last summer if making the playoffs seemed crazy, and consider Cory Schneider wasn't good at all: I would say the answer would have been yes.

     

    Colorado made that massive leap out of nowhere years ago, ask them that summer before the season 'can you make the playoffs' they would have said 'Are you nuts'

    We all know about Vegas...

     

    Toronto was on a good path, but they elevated to the playoffs a lot faster then most thought.

     

    Those teams have Hall, Matthews, and MacKinnon. We have Eichel. None of those teams had elite goaltending, with the exception of Vegas, but Vegas is probably the weakest of these examples.  Defense? Toronto has an average D at best, NJ is average too and Colorado did not have anything special to note. 

    I see NO reason why Buffalo can't surprise and do the same. The odds are low, but it really can happen.


    The salary cap era has created these opportunities to make leaps much faster then anyone could have hoped for.

     

    Absolutely right. We've seen massive turnarounds from one season to the next. This is why it is frustrating to me, given our woeful history the past several seasons, that we have a GM who is selling us on yet another long, slow, methodical building process, which IMHO is outdated. We already have a bunch of young top-10 picks on the roster (Eichel, Reinhardt, Risto, Mittelstadt, Dahlin, maybe Nylander), yet we're still trading assets for more picks and prospects. I don't like that one bit. As such, I think we'll again be terrible this season. Hopefully Mittelstadt and Dahlin develop - and ideally show flashes of brilliance - during their rookie seasons. Tage is another guy who really needs to show something. If he produces, the ROR trade will look a whole lot better. It'd also really be nice if Ullmark shows he is a legit NHL #1 this season. To me those are the things to look forward to this season. I don't think this team is anywhere close to a playoff run... yet...

  2. I wish I could have the blind optimism that some of you do, but the roster as it stands is awful. Certainly there is some young talent, but that is almost entirely a function of a steady stream of top-10 picks courtesy of sucking so badly for the past 7/8 seasons. The team got 20 points worse under Botterill/Housley last season…. and we just ditched two 20+ goal scorers from the lowest scoring offense in the league. I don't see why putting together the worst team in the league, lucking into the first overall pick via the draft lottery, then selecting the obvious consensus #1 player on everyone's board constitutes great GM work by Botterill. Any one of us on this board could have done that.

    I'll continue to hope for miracles and I'll never root against my team (I was decided anti-tank back in the day).... but I honestly believe we'll finish dead last, or close to it, again this season. Happy Independence Day y'all!

     

    • Like (+1) 2
  3. James is out for Columbia.

     

    Has he done anything since the last WC?

     

    He's had a calf issue for a while. Played about a game and a half this World Cup. Colombia isn't nearly as dangerous offensively without him.

    This game is what is wrong with soccer.

     

     

    I go down to Colombia each fall for work. You should see their domestic league. It's downright dangerous. Yet, strangely awesome.

  4. People forget that under GMTM and Dan Bylsma the Buffalo Sabres improved from 50 points to 80 points in one season.  

     

    After the 81 point season, they dropped to 78 points because Eichel missed half the year.     So they all get fired, and then they drop to 62 points under JBOT and Housley in what was supposed to be year they showed progress and sniffed a playoff spot after improving the roster and playing the modern NHL game vs Bylsma's archaic (albeit successful) system.  

     

    Truth. GMTM gets hammered around here and he certainly made some bad moves - IMHO mostly overpaying for certain guys that he wanted - but he also made some bold trades. And, after engineering the tank to get Eichel, the team did improve afterward as you note. Then he gets fired (I assume it was mostly a personality conflict with the Pegulas) and we hire Botterill who immediately takes the team back to dead-last in the NHL. Last season was atrocious. I figured Botterill would make some moves last summer to bolster the team, but he didn't do much of anything other than sign AHL guys. And, we just jettisoned two of the few guys on the roster who could actually put the puck in the net. Lottery tickets and hope. Another rebuild. Trust the process.   

     

    :angry: 

  5. Note Thompson's comments about coming here.  He said that the Blues couldn't/wouldn't tolerate mistakes.  I think this may have the biggest effect.  And it's no longer coming from a minority in the room.

     

    This one isn't hard to translate. That's Mike Yeo's reputation (won't tolerate mistakes) and is why he lost the team in Minnesota.

  6. ROR said alot.  He never quit on the ice.

     

    They guy he apparently lost an internal struggle to did actually quit on the ice.  And was rewarded with a monster deal in the following offseason.

     

    I agree. The guy gave everything he had on every shift for a team that was absolutely awful. At the end of the year he expressed his frustration with all the losing... rightfully so for a competitive, proud player... and suddenly got lambasted as a "bad guy" and "locker-room cancer." Pretty unfair IMHO. We can argue whether he is a good player or not, fast enough, is a true #2 center, blah, blah, blah... but nothing in his game said he lacked character and heart on the ice. Nothing.

     

    My guess is he asked for a trade out. Seven straight seasons with no playoffs for this franchise, with no end in sight. I can't imagine anyone in the prime of their career would want to play for this organization.

  7. Can Boogie play in a system designed around team ball though?

     

    He's recovering from a torn Achilles, so he may not be ready to go until December or so. I think most teams were reluctantly to give him a long-term deal until he shows he can still play at the same level. So, he took 1/3 of the money for a 1-year deal and a great chance at a ring. He's not a great defender, but is a matchup nightmare offensively and is a dominant rebounder. He'll get fewer minutes in Oakland, so he'll be effective. He fit in well with the Pels up-tempo system and the Warriors have the exact same system (our coach was an assistant under Steve Kerr prior to coming to New Orleans).

     

    The Pels were on a tear beating the best teams in the NBA when Boogie tore his Achilles in garbage time during a win over the Rockets. That effectively killed the Pels season.

  8. i can't believe the Lakers just renounced the rights to Julius Randle in order to free up cap space to sign...Rajon Rondo. LeBron continues to demonstrate his basketball IQ doesn't extend to player personnel decisions.

     

    Eleven, how do you feel about this? :P

     

    Rondo dominates in the playoffs. He's a coach on the floor and still one of the best assist guys in the league. Sorry to see him leave New Orleans. He was a great fit here.

  9. FWIW, Andy Strickland was on WGR this morning and my take was that he pointed the finger at Jack. His claim is that he has spoken to other vets who didn't mesh well with him.

     

    I can buy this. Cocky kid who comes into the league as the next "generational talent" and thus far has been good but certainly not "generational."

  10. I'm just not understanding the love for JBott thus far other than blind optimism. He's had one season as an NHL GM and we finished dead last in the league by a fairly wide margin (Ottawa gave us a bit of a run). We had the worst goal differential by a wide margin. We were the only team not to score 200 goals on the season. He did exceedingly little last off-season other than trading for Scandella and acquiring a pile of nobodies. Then he took two of the four/five guys on the roster who can actually put the puck in the net and sent them on their way - both guys in their prime. And, thus far has signed a career backup goalie, Scott "Goodwill" Wilson, Svobotka, Berglund, .... we're terrible. Our roster is a collection of crap with some young, high draft picks sprinkled in. How in the wide world of sports can anyone see any cause for optimism other than the high draft picks we keep getting every year because we suck so badly? Middlestadt and Dahlin should be very good players... but any one of us on this board could create a terrible team then figure out who to draft in the top-10. That's easy. Tearing apart a roster is easy. Until we turn the corner... if that ever happens... I just can't praise any of what JBott is doing. This is a decade of sucking with no end in sight.

     

     

    *end of rant*

     

     

     

  11. The reality is Wilson is a dime-a-dozen player who wouldn't be on the roster of a top team. We grabbed him off of waivers; he played for three teams last season. Unless Dahlin is the defensive version of McJesus, moves like this (giving a two-year contract to Scott Wilson) show me we're going to suck again this season.

     

     

     

     

  12. And they could very well be approaching the point of moving picks to supplement the roster.  Time will tell with that.  What we shouldn't do is be held accountable for the sins of previous GMs.  If he is handed a team that needs a ton of reshuffling, he needs to do exactly that regardless of what just happened a couple years before he got here.  All of that is sunk at this point.  Sure it sucks for us the fans, but if Botterill seriously believes something needs to be done to make this organization better, he needs to do exactly that.  Screw the fans.

     

     

    If he takes all/some of the three 1st round picks we have next year (ours, San Jose, St. Louis) and uses them for a talented player who can help us right now then I can live with the recent "tear down" moves. But, if he plans to keep acquiring picks ad nauseum then the current core will be gone before we can field a winning team.

     

    In most businesses, yes, I agree that (the equivalent of) the "fans" don't matter. Do what you need to do. Sports is a bit different in that there are dual goals. One is a championship, but I would argue that the other is profit with the product being entertainment. Fielding last place teams every year obviously hurt with the latter.

  13. The problem is that none of us wanted to see a second tear-down and re-build, and that's what we're getting.  Maybe he's right to do it; maybe not--but none of us wanted to see it.

     

    This is my take. The context matters. A tear-down can easily be sold to fans when you have a team of aging vets who weren't quite good enough to get you to the promised land (e.g. Vancouver with the Sedins). But, we just had a tear-down and our core guys are presumably already here in Dahlin, Risto, Jack, Samson, and Mittelstadt. We don't need more picks. We need to surround the young talent we have with some solid veterans who can help them develop. I just don't think we're in the "trade your vets for picks" phase any more.

  14. Since it was so bothersome, I'm going to apologize for my emotional explosion here. 

     

    My real problem is that I see a bad trade as a culmination of bad asset management dating back to Botterill's first decisions here, and it makes me equally pessimistic about the future in a league with high parity and high turnover. In today's NHL, you have to practically try to be this bad for this long and in my eyes we've shown no ability to line-build, line-match, or roster-build on the level of even average NHL teams that we blew things up to stop being.

     

    Werd. We've been terrible for almost a decade. I think most of us are going to be naturally skeptical at this point, especially when we see a trade that doesn't pass the eye test. Trying to spin everything as a great move just doesn't resonate when we've seen move after move yield null results over the past several season. In this case, we let our second leading scorer, best defensive forward, and the best faceoff guy in the NHL walk for a marginal prospect, two salary dump forwards and a couple of picks (the 1st is cap protected BTW - we don't get it if it is top-10). Scoring 60 points on the worst offensive team in hockey is nothing to sneeze at. We were poor offensively last season and we just let two of the few guys who can put the puck in the net (Kane, ROR) leave. Dahlin will help greatly, but I just don't see any way this team isn't at the bottom of the standings again this season. Our overall talent pales in comparison to our rivals.

×
×
  • Create New...