Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
13 hours ago, RETURNTOGLORY said:

What exactly did Jarmo Kekäläinen do this offseason to make the Buffalo Sabres better?

We lost two key players in Alex Tuch and Bowen Byram. We didn’t get Connor Hellebuyck. The goaltending remains horrible. The power play is dead last in the league. The penalty kill is dead last, too.

These were issues we were discussing at the END of last season. Management had an entire offseason to address them. Instead, we’re watching the same weaknesses undermine this team, with two important players gone.

Spare me the “it’s early” excuse. That might explain a new problem. It doesn’t excuse carrying familiar problems into another season without adequately addressing them.

And yes, acquiring Hellebuyck would have required a substantial return. If the price was unreasonable, you move on—but you still need another answer in goal. Failing to complete one particular trade doesn’t erase the responsibility to improve the position.

The coaches are accountable for special teams. The players are accountable for execution. But who supplies the personnel? Who decides which players leave, which players arrive, and whether the goaltending is good enough?

That’s the general manager.

Kekäläinen was hired for his experience and judgment. Where is the evidence of either in the way these weaknesses have been addressed?

Buffalo fans shouldn’t have to keep lowering their expectations to make management’s work look acceptable. We deserve a better team, and right now, I don’t see how his offseason delivered one.

I look at it as one key player gone: Tuch.   I didn’t like him leaving because he was one of my favorite players, but the impact of the loss is major.  He was a stalwart on the PK.  Many comments on this board say the team needs a top winger.  Well, he is one. I don’t believe any winger on this team outside of Tage is going to score 30 goals this season, which is what Tuch did in 3 of the last 4 years. 
 

it’s unfortunate that the market resulted in the deal that Tuch received from Washington, as signing a player his age for 8 years, to his age 38 season was very risky.   This team is still having to deal with the effects of the Skinner contract.

However, to beat the new CBA, the team goes and signs an unproven Östlund to an 8 year deal, all be it for less money.  Hopefully he fulfills expectations.

  • Agree 3
Posted

Yes, losing Tuch hurts, but in three years when Tuch isn't playing well anymore and the Capitals are still paying him a ton, and the Sabres AREN'T paying him a ton, we'll be happy.  If Tuch had come on board earlier in his career, giving him the big long-term contract would have made sense.  Letting him go was the right move for a team NOT at the ready-to-win-it-all stage -- not with the goaltending situation.  

  • Like (+1) 2
  • Haha (+1) 1
Posted
24 minutes ago, Alaska John said:

Yes, losing Tuch hurts, but in three years when Tuch isn't playing well anymore and the Capitals are still paying him a ton, and the Sabres AREN'T paying him a ton, we'll be happy.  If Tuch had come on board earlier in his career, giving him the big long-term contract would have made sense.  Letting him go was the right move for a team NOT at the ready-to-win-it-all stage -- not with the goaltending situation.  

That's exactly the kind of thinking that has kept this franchise stuck in mediocrity for years. We're constantly worrying about what a player might look like three or four years down the road instead of addressing what this team desperately needs RIGHT NOW.

Tuch was a proven, productive player who brought leadership, physicality, experience, and consistency to a roster that desperately needs all four. You don't replace that simply by saving cap space and hoping someone else develops into the same caliber of player.

And the argument that we're not ready to win because of our goaltending actually makes my point. Whose responsibility is it to fix the goaltending? Whose responsibility is it to build a competitive roster? You don't justify weakening one part of your team because management has failed to address another.

At some point, this organization needs to stop planning for a future that never seems to arrive. We've spent well over a decade hearing about development, patience, prospects, and financial flexibility. Meanwhile, other organizations manage to retain their productive veterans, address their weaknesses, and compete.

I'd much rather worry about Tuch's contract three years from now than continue watching this franchise sacrifice the present for some imaginary future.

Cap space doesn't score goals, kill penalties, or win hockey games. Players do.

  • Agree 3
  • Thanks (+1) 1
Posted
2 hours ago, RETURNTOGLORY said:

That's exactly the kind of thinking that has kept this franchise stuck in mediocrity for years. We're constantly worrying about what a player might look like three or four years down the road instead of addressing what this team desperately needs RIGHT NOW.

Tuch was a proven, productive player who brought leadership, physicality, experience, and consistency to a roster that desperately needs all four. You don't replace that simply by saving cap space and hoping someone else develops into the same caliber of player.

And the argument that we're not ready to win because of our goaltending actually makes my point. Whose responsibility is it to fix the goaltending? Whose responsibility is it to build a competitive roster? You don't justify weakening one part of your team because management has failed to address another.

At some point, this organization needs to stop planning for a future that never seems to arrive. We've spent well over a decade hearing about development, patience, prospects, and financial flexibility. Meanwhile, other organizations manage to retain their productive veterans, address their weaknesses, and compete.

I'd much rather worry about Tuch's contract three years from now than continue watching this franchise sacrifice the present for some imaginary future.

Cap space doesn't score goals, kill penalties, or win hockey games. Players do.

So I'm still confused on the whole Tuch thing...what was the offer...what was the contract that he wanted in order to stay in Buffalo that he wasn't offered before he sighed with the Caps?  Was offering him the exact same deal he got in Washington, was that enough to keep him here and the Sabres refused to do that?

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
1 hour ago, mjd1001 said:

So I'm still confused on the whole Tuch thing...what was the offer...what was the contract that he wanted in order to stay in Buffalo that he wasn't offered before he sighed with the Caps?  Was offering him the exact same deal he got in Washington, was that enough to keep him here and the Sabres refused to do that?


From what has been reported, Tuch was looking for approximately $10.5 million annually on a long-term contract, which is exactly what he received from Washington: eight years, $84 million.


According to NHL insider Pierre LeBrun, Buffalo's final offer was reportedly seven years at somewhere between just under $10 million and approximately $10 million annually. That would put Buffalo's offer around $70 million, compared to Washington's $84 million.


Tuch himself confirmed that the Sabres increased their offer late in negotiations but acknowledged there was still a gap. He declined to disclose the exact figures.


So, to answer your question, there is no public confirmation that Buffalo ever offered him the same contract Washington did. In fact, the reporting suggests they didn't.


Would matching Washington's offer have convinced Tuch to stay? Nobody can say with absolute certainty, but considering he reportedly wanted $10.5 million annually and ultimately accepted exactly that, it's certainly reasonable to believe it could have.


My bigger issue is that Buffalo knew what Tuch was looking for, knew what he meant to this team, and still couldn't get a deal done. Then they watched him leave without acquiring an established replacement.


At some point, management needs to be held accountable for the talent leaving this organization, particularly when the same roster weaknesses continue to be exposed.

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
56 minutes ago, RETURNTOGLORY said:


From what has been reported, Tuch was looking for approximately $10.5 million annually on a long-term contract, which is exactly what he received from Washington: eight years, $84 million.


According to NHL insider Pierre LeBrun, Buffalo's final offer was reportedly seven years at somewhere between just under $10 million and approximately $10 million annually. That would put Buffalo's offer around $70 million, compared to Washington's $84 million.


Tuch himself confirmed that the Sabres increased their offer late in negotiations but acknowledged there was still a gap. He declined to disclose the exact figures.


So, to answer your question, there is no public confirmation that Buffalo ever offered him the same contract Washington did. In fact, the reporting suggests they didn't.


Would matching Washington's offer have convinced Tuch to stay? Nobody can say with absolute certainty, but considering he reportedly wanted $10.5 million annually and ultimately accepted exactly that, it's certainly reasonable to believe it could have.


My bigger issue is that Buffalo knew what Tuch was looking for, knew what he meant to this team, and still couldn't get a deal done. Then they watched him leave without acquiring an established replacement.


At some point, management needs to be held accountable for the talent leaving this organization, particularly when the same roster weaknesses continue to be exposed.

This matches what I remember reading also. Even if the Sabres got closer towards the end, if the reports that buffalo was unwilling to go to 8 years, thats 8-14M difference in offers.

That is a lot of money for a person and not so much money for a billionaire, so I am still surprised that Buffalo was being stingy. 

 

The whole Tuch situation and sticking so hard to that number is what made me think there was SOME additional moves coming, why be so strict on that number if you are just going to sit on it. That does seem to indicate that next offseason will be the big swings but letting it fly from the hip immediately after finally making the playoffs seems a big risk to me. 

There was pretty much no situation, even if Byram and Tuch stayed that the sabres would match or exceed their season last year, so I am sure Jarmo expected some regression but I doubt he expected half of the players who needed to step up to just... not

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted

Am I the only one that remembers the Sabres having the exact same record at this point in the season last year and then winning the division?  Does that mean a Tuch/Byram team is just as good (or terrible) as a Tuchless/Bye-Byram team?  

No I don't want them to need another 10+ game heater, but I also don't need them to win the division again either.  Most of the teams are 2-3 games within each other in the standings.

What they need to do is fix the PP/PK and start scoring goals in bunches again. 

 

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Agree 2
  • Thanks (+1) 1
Posted
5 hours ago, Alaska John said:

Yes, losing Tuch hurts, but in three years when Tuch isn't playing well anymore and the Capitals are still paying him a ton, and the Sabres AREN'T paying him a ton, we'll be happy.  If Tuch had come on board earlier in his career, giving him the big long-term contract would have made sense.  Letting him go was the right move for a team NOT at the ready-to-win-it-all stage -- not with the goaltending situation.  

I won’t disagree with this….BUT, it still was incumbent on Jarmo to have some kind of backfill solution to Tuch’s departure.  Promoting from within with unproven youth is too risky when you have a franchise that still needs to prove they are a contender.

  • Like (+1) 3
Posted
1 hour ago, Carmel Corn said:

I won’t disagree with this….BUT, it still was incumbent on Jarmo to have some kind of backfill solution to Tuch’s departure.  Promoting from within with unproven youth is too risky when you have a franchise that still needs to prove they are a contender.

I think Jarmo sees this team as a wildcard team as built (which I tend to agree with). Is that so bad? I dont think there was anyway the sabres surpass 109 points even if we kept byram and tuch and upgraded the goaltending. 109 points and that run last year, as much as we dont want to admit it, was an outlier... how far of an outlier remains to be seen but right now it seems pretty out there

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted (edited)

One thing I wonder about is the 7 vs 8 years.  If you are Jarmo there is no guarantee he will even be here 8 years from now, so why would he care so much about 7 vs 8 years. He knows deep down this is a better team this year, next year, with Tuch.  He knows his job security is better if the team is better. So, what i wonder is this a decision that was made above the GM, that no we're not committing to that money, that many years?

Edited by sabresfan714
Posted

Paging Dylan Larkin to the white courtesy phone....

He hasn't shown an interest in Buffalo yet, but I think he might be the best available Tuch replacement.

Posted
On 10/25/2026 at 11:17 AM, RETURNTOGLORY said:

What exactly did Jarmo Kekäläinen do this offseason to make the Buffalo Sabres better?

We lost two key players in Alex Tuch and Bowen Byram. We didn’t get Connor Hellebuyck. The goaltending remains horrible. The power play is dead last in the league. The penalty kill is dead last, too.

These were issues we were discussing at the END of last season. Management had an entire offseason to address them. Instead, we’re watching the same weaknesses undermine this team, with two important players gone.

Spare me the “it’s early” excuse. That might explain a new problem. It doesn’t excuse carrying familiar problems into another season without adequately addressing them.

And yes, acquiring Hellebuyck would have required a substantial return. If the price was unreasonable, you move on—but you still need another answer in goal. Failing to complete one particular trade doesn’t erase the responsibility to improve the position.

The coaches are accountable for special teams. The players are accountable for execution. But who supplies the personnel? Who decides which players leave, which players arrive, and whether the goaltending is good enough?

That’s the general manager.

Kekäläinen was hired for his experience and judgment. Where is the evidence of either in the way these weaknesses have been addressed?

Buffalo fans shouldn’t have to keep lowering their expectations to make management’s work look acceptable. We deserve a better team, and right now, I don’t see how his offseason delivered one.

I'd say its early in the context of his tenure as a GM.  He traded an expensive 1-yr expiring contract that we were going to have challenges extending for the 4th overall pick, crevier, and the pick they used in the zellweger trade.  I don't think either player acquisition can be fully judged on this short of a timeline, as well as the main future being Rudolph.  Tuch's contract is more likely to be judged in what it looks like 5 years from now vs. today, but I do wish they did more there than just rely solely on young players all making a leap.  

As for the state of the current team - they were 3rd in team goaltending last year, currently they're 31st.  I think the truth lies somewhere in between, but they could use Lyon at this point.  Last year they were 5th in shooting%, this year they're 21st.  The PK is a disaster, the goalies haven't made plays there either.  They have played pretty bad so far this year and are still... in the thick of it.  But they don't look very good at the moment - and you shouldn't count on flipping some switch later in the year and winning games.  Need to win games now too.  

  • Agree 1
Posted
10 hours ago, Alaska John said:

Yes, losing Tuch hurts, but in three years when Tuch isn't playing well anymore and the Capitals are still paying him a ton, and the Sabres AREN'T paying him a ton, we'll be happy.  If Tuch had come on board earlier in his career, giving him the big long-term contract would have made sense.  Letting him go was the right move for a team NOT at the ready-to-win-it-all stage -- not with the goaltending situation.  

Yes.  In three years Thompson and Dahlin could be gone we will be doing what?   Cheering for Kulich and Helenius?  

They should have extended him in his 2nd last season, but they waited, and the cap went up as planned, and the Kempe deal happened, and look at it now.  

This team has a history of losing good players on the 3rd contract "because they are getting old".   Could that be just one more reason they made the payoffs 1 time in 15 years.   

Pass me my beer Sabre.  

Excited Buffalo Sabres GIF by Respective

 

 

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Agree 1
Posted
16 hours ago, Crusader1969 said:

I think the point is that they are playing bad and still at .500.  We know it's not good enough to make the playoffs but at least they aren't buried. A good road trip out west where they take 3 of 4 and they will be right back in it 

Right. If .500 represents our worst stretch of hockey or closer to our worst stretch and it just so happened to be the one we kicked off the season with, we should be in decent shape to snag a playoff spot 

If it’s the norm..well that stinks.

But I don’t believe that to be the case

  • Like (+1) 2
  • Agree 1
Posted
31 minutes ago, Nacho Libre said:

Right. If .500 represents our worst stretch of hockey or closer to our worst stretch and it just so happened to be the one we kicked off the season with, we should be in decent shape to snag a playoff spot 

If it’s the norm..well that stinks.

But I don’t believe that to be the case

Probably not a complete coincidence that shortly after Zucker got back they actually had a 2 goal lead in this last game.  This team can use a veteran presence.

Getting Timmins back will help the PK.  Getting Lyon back will likely help the GTing.

Will it be enough?  No data.  Darn shame UPL gave up that 3rd goal in the Fill game.  Really thought they were coming back and if they had they'd've been right at 0.600 through 10 and would only need to go 2-1-1 over the next 4 to get back to 0.600.  To get it all back in this segment they need 3-0-1 which seems a lot tougher (even though it's the difference in scoring a goal in the last 5 minutes of a 2-2 game vs giving up the goal in the last 5 minutes of regulation in a 2-2 game).

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Thanks (+1) 1
Posted
17 hours ago, Carmel Corn said:

I won’t disagree with this….BUT, it still was incumbent on Jarmo to have some kind of backfill solution to Tuch’s departure.  Promoting from within with unproven youth is too risky when you have a franchise that still needs to prove they are a contender.

I agree completely.  Tuch isn't the only player in the league.  Others were and are available.  The young players are showing they're still not ready to be leaders.  

  • Agree 1
Posted (edited)
On 10/26/2026 at 6:07 AM, RETURNTOGLORY said:


From what has been reported, Tuch was looking for approximately $10.5 million annually on a long-term contract, which is exactly what he received from Washington: eight years, $84 million.


According to NHL insider Pierre LeBrun, Buffalo's final offer was reportedly seven years at somewhere between just under $10 million and approximately $10 million annually. That would put Buffalo's offer around $70 million, compared to Washington's $84 million.


Tuch himself confirmed that the Sabres increased their offer late in negotiations but acknowledged there was still a gap. He declined to disclose the exact figures.


So, to answer your question, there is no public confirmation that Buffalo ever offered him the same contract Washington did. In fact, the reporting suggests they didn't.


Would matching Washington's offer have convinced Tuch to stay? Nobody can say with absolute certainty, but considering he reportedly wanted $10.5 million annually and ultimately accepted exactly that, it's certainly reasonable to believe it could have.


My bigger issue is that Buffalo knew what Tuch was looking for, knew what he meant to this team, and still couldn't get a deal done. Then they watched him leave without acquiring an established replacement.


At some point, management needs to be held accountable for the talent leaving this organization, particularly when the same roster weaknesses continue to be exposed.

The question I would have loved to see posed to Tuch is:  “Was there an ask that you had that if the Sabres had met, would have kept you in Buffalo?”  That addresses the speculation on whether he was leaving no matter what. If he can’t answer yes to that question, then it was not necessarily about money. If the answer is yes, I can’t imagine the ask was greater than what he or Kempe signed for. 

Edited by Archie Lee
  • Agree 2
Posted
5 hours ago, Alaska John said:

I agree completely.  Tuch isn't the only player in the league.  Others were and are available.  The young players are showing they're still not ready to be leaders.  

As I have been saying for several years, there is no true leader on this team. We need someone with fire and passion lacing them up every game. It's infectious!

  • Agree 2
Posted
2 minutes ago, RETURNTOGLORY said:

As I have been saying for several years, there is no true leader on this team. We need someone with fire and passion lacing them up every game. It's infectious!

But... but...  Krebs reads the lineup card with gusto. WGR seems very proud of that.

  • Haha (+1) 1
Posted
On 10/25/2026 at 12:27 PM, dudacek said:

Jarmo put his faith in the following players:

Norris: pacing for 21 points, -35

Benson: no goals in 11 games, pacing for 49 points

Doan: pacing for 21 points 

McLeod: pacing for 21 points, -35

Kulich: pacing for 10 goals and 30 points 

Helenius: pacing for 8 goals and 8 assists, -24

Dahlin: pacing for 50 points

The GM deserves the heat, but it’s remarkable to me how many of these players arent getting the same treatment for simply not doing their jobs.

 

This cannot be denied... why, I dont know, I think its probably the makeup of the team... I just dont see them as an edgy difficult to play against team...  Benson and Doan after getting the bag are massive disappointments... early still but your hope was they would fill some leadership up front when Tuch was deemed not important enough to retain... effectively his money went to these two... 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...